Insights

CNA scorecard

How well each CVE Numbering Authority fills the records it publishes, scored against a published set of rules: Describe, Scope, Assess, Act, 25 points each. Only what the assigner wrote itself counts; severity and weaknesses added later by an ADP are shown as a dependency, not as the assigner's work.

212
Ranked CNAs
170
Under the threshold
180 days
Rolling window
12
Grade A
# CNA Grade Score Records Badge
1 secur0 A 98.62 47
2 temporal A 97.2 15
3 eef A 96.86 354
4 palo_alto A 95.07 78
5 isc A 95.0 27
6 amzn A 94.28 163
7 moxa A 93.8 14
8 qt A 92.5 34
9 netgear A 92.06 42
10 checkmk A 91.56 25
11 watchguard A 91.23 93
12 circl A 90.6 257
13 sonatype B 89.91 35
14 cert-in B 89.87 24
15 autodesk B 89.81 32
16 fluid attacks B 89.73 63
17 wso2 B 89.17 68
18 ibm B 87.89 1,651
19 checkmarx B 87.7 24
20 docker B 87.59 47
21 tplink B 87.43 109
22 arista B 87.23 116
23 hackrate B 87.16 11
24 harborist B 86.57 22
25 dsf B 86.25 24
26 qnap B 85.61 63
27 f5 B 85.25 35
28 incibe B 84.84 156
29 asustor1 B 84.8 10
30 concretecms B 84.36 111
31 vulncheck B 84.25 8,260
32 silabs B 84.16 40
33 juniper B 84.15 193
34 github_p B 84.05 22
35 ni B 83.99 28
36 bcorg B 83.74 73
37 vuldb B 83.23 3,859
38 solarwinds B 82.97 30
39 lenovo B 82.93 50
40 typo3 B 82.66 66
41 sec-vlab B 82.56 23
42 kong B 82.34 27
43 redhat B 82.2 1,198
44 canonical B 82.08 62
45 herodevs B 81.94 18
46 suse B 81.84 125
47 microsoft B 81.79 4,921
48 php B 81.68 17
49 gv B 81.67 78
50 rti B 81.37 19
51 cert-pl B 81.3 267
52 nlnet labs B 81.18 65
53 tv B 80.93 18
54 mandiant B 80.62 20
55 securin B 80.45 66
56 nozomi B 80.45 55
57 twcert B 80.17 95
58 mattermost B 79.71 109
59 wolfssl B 79.71 51
60 n-able B 79.7 14
61 deltaww B 79.33 21
62 zabbix B 79.29 17
63 ncsc.ch B 79.02 85
64 hitachi B 79.01 54
65 glibc B 78.96 16
66 progresssoftware B 78.94 203
67 psf B 78.5 32
68 opentext B 78.28 18
69 openssl B 78.0 48
70 google B 77.52 38
71 zephyr B 77.42 238
72 fortra B 77.26 13
73 googlecloud B 77.07 30
74 enisa B 76.87 70
75 apache B 76.17 1,266
76 cyberdanube B 76.0 20
77 zenitel B 75.91 11
78 rapid7 B 75.83 78
79 divd B 75.69 18
80 cisa-cg B 75.66 138
81 certvde B 75.63 167
82 jfrog B 75.62 67
83 patchstack B 75.6 3,623
84 brocade B 75.46 70
85 gen B 75.21 24
86 icscert B 75.18 337
87 acer B 75.08 48
88 rt-labs B 75.0 20
89 otrs B 75.0 17
90 ncsc B 75.0 10
91 document fdn. C 74.76 21
92 zuso art C 74.73 11
93 adobe C 74.68 879
94 hp C 74.63 35
95 rami.io C 74.62 25
96 tr-cert C 74.5 276
97 jci C 74.47 42
98 altium C 74.38 13
99 gitlab C 74.24 303
100 kaspersky C 74.23 10
101 zohocorp C 73.83 70
102 rockwell C 73.81 47
103 openvpn C 73.46 29
104 grafana C 73.39 59
105 aha C 73.27 11
106 perforce C 73.11 16
107 joomla C 72.79 381
108 zdi C 72.21 191
109 asus C 72.05 52
110 fortinet C 71.94 145
111 tenable C 71.88 46
112 hdfg C 71.67 18
113 github_m C 71.54 7,840
114 runzero C 71.52 26
115 airbus C 70.45 15
116 blackberry C 70.05 16
117 hashicorp C 70.0 51
118 hiddenlayer C 70.0 15
119 mongodb C 69.99 260
120 eric C 69.92 15
121 incd C 69.8 15
122 foxit C 69.71 68
123 turansec C 69.7 189
124 dell C 69.61 575
125 wikimedia-foundation C 69.61 70
126 zyxel C 69.53 11
127 oracle C 69.3 3,977
128 fedora C 69.25 44
129 ami C 69.25 10
130 zte C 69.07 29
131 elastic C 68.98 173
132 hitachi energy C 68.79 15
133 supermicro C 68.36 11
134 postgresql C 68.01 155
135 zscaler C 67.9 10
136 abb C 67.88 17
137 acronis C 67.63 18
138 edb C 67.48 10
139 okta C 67.42 35
140 redhat-cnalr C 67.22 10
141 canva C 66.8 15
142 cisco C 66.26 427
143 openjs C 66.11 149
144 eclipse C 65.68 219
145 citrix C 65.6 10
146 checkpoint C 65.58 20
147 snowflake C 65.45 22
148 sap C 65.15 144
149 esri C 65.09 29
150 siemens C 65.0 88
151 @huntr_ai C 65.0 35
152 wordfence C 64.99 2,418
153 nvidia C 64.75 325
154 schneider C 64.55 20
155 hcl C 64.41 184
156 synology C 64.3 73
157 vmware C 64.29 226
158 jpcert C 63.8 185
159 3ds C 63.57 21
160 samsung.tv_appliance C 63.29 41
161 amd C 62.95 67
162 ivanti C 62.88 41
163 octopus C 62.23 26
164 ox C 62.21 47
165 csa C 61.83 60
166 sn C 61.54 13
167 qualcomm C 61.47 79
168 atlassian C 61.2 10
169 cpansec C 60.92 359
170 commvault C 60.88 24
171 gitea C 60.8 205
172 snyk C 60.45 11
173 zoom C 60.29 17
174 intel C 60.0 174
175 talos C 60.0 49
176 mautic C 60.0 16
177 freebsd D 59.8 61
178 tanium D 59.76 87
179 hackerone D 59.58 228
180 netscaler D 59.18 47
181 absolute D 59.0 24
182 ubiquiti D 58.57 42
183 axis D 57.68 22
184 ly-corporation D 57.31 16
185 jetbrains D 57.05 245
186 huawei D 57.0 65
187 trendmicro D 57.0 16
188 hpe D 56.41 392
189 xen D 55.78 46
190 imaginationtech D 54.79 39
191 samsungmobile D 54.64 154
192 unisoc D 54.61 14
193 sonicwall D 54.27 34
194 linux D 53.08 6,660
195 drupal D 52.75 272
196 arm D 51.5 14
197 curl D 46.12 51
198 mediatek D 45.0 151
199 devolutions E 44.39 78
200 meta E 44.38 16
201 jenkins E 44.31 140
202 wpscan E 44.05 2,249
203 chrome E 42.86 3,519
204 certcc E 42.15 180
205 go E 41.89 76
206 samsungsemiconductor E 41.4 35
207 nokia E 39.7 10
208 google_android E 38.93 336
209 mozilla E 37.66 750
210 google_devices E 37.61 301
211 apple E 36.8 906
212 mitre E 28.97 2,124
Under the threshold (170)

Fewer than 10 publications in the window. The score is indicative and these are not ranked: three perfect records are not evidence of a practice.

hackrtu 100.0 4 records
posit 96.8 2 records
nutanix 96.8 1 record
tqtc 96.0 4 records
ocd 96.0 2 records
netdef 94.6 5 records
tha-psirt 92.69 7 records
velneo 92.0 2 records
arcinfo 91.8 2 records
fti 91.8 2 records
hw 91.4 2 records
neo4j 90.86 7 records
rust 90.5 2 records
mon-csirt 89.8 8 records
axxonsoft 89.8 5 records
cribl 89.8 2 records
milestone 89.8 1 record
roche 89.8 1 record
sirius 89.8 1 record
strongdm 89.8 1 record
vestel 89.8 1 record
illumos 89.11 9 records
tigera 89.0 6 records
omicron 88.47 3 records
esaqa 88.0 6 records
echo 88.0 2 records
danfoss 88.0 1 record
wrensecurity 88.0 1 record
microchip 87.04 9 records
algosec 87.0 1 record
bull 86.8 1 record
postiz 86.75 8 records
canon_emea 86.72 5 records
flock 86.55 4 records
grayback 86.29 7 records
libreswan 85.75 8 records
chainguard 85.33 6 records
mitsubishi 84.8 8 records
nx 84.8 2 records
openam-jp 84.8 1 record
asrg 84.38 8 records
schutzwerk 84.33 3 records
softing 84.0 1 record
fermax 83.55 4 records
star_labs 83.0 1 record
sra 82.74 7 records
tcpdump 82.57 7 records
prjblk 82.4 6 records
blackduck 82.3 4 records
delinea 82.03 8 records
netskope 82.03 7 records
logitech 82.0 1 record
semtech 82.0 1 record
wibu 81.8 8 records
flexera 81.77 6 records
opennms 81.56 9 records
ptc 81.4 5 records
altera 80.88 8 records
m-files corporation 80.13 3 records
vaadin 80.0 8 records
hsi 80.0 1 record
nintendo 80.0 1 record
securepoint 80.0 1 record
extremenetworks 79.9 4 records
thinkstappliedresearch 79.8 7 records
linqi 79.8 4 records
sick ag 79.8 3 records
illumio 79.8 2 records
kubernetes 79.56 5 records
ping identity 79.4 5 records
dotcms 79.0 2 records
toreon 79.0 2 records
pandorafms 78.88 8 records
krcert 78.5 6 records
cirosec 78.4 2 records
forcepoint 78.0 3 records
ncsc-fi 77.95 4 records
centreon 77.55 4 records
tlt_net 77.5 5 records
crowdstrike 77.0 1 record
lge 77.0 1 record
seal 76.86 7 records
bitdefender 76.25 8 records
digi 76.15 4 records
payara 76.15 4 records
cato 75.95 4 records
symantec 75.17 6 records
bt 75.0 7 records
knime 75.0 7 records
caliptra 75.0 5 records
watchdog 75.0 3 records
ea 75.0 1 record
elan 75.0 1 record
forescout 75.0 1 record
proton 75.0 1 record
yandex 75.0 1 record
alibaba 74.9 2 records
hitvan 74.5 6 records
tml 74.3 6 records
yeswehack 73.33 3 records
openeuler 73.0 4 records
b.braun 73.0 3 records
tcs-cert 73.0 3 records
eset 72.75 8 records
canon 72.55 8 records
pega 72.5 6 records
clickhouse 72.0 1 record
iqsight 71.8 1 record
connectwise 71.75 4 records
honeywell 71.07 7 records
sophos 71.0 2 records
papercut 70.56 9 records
blsops 70.0 8 records
akrites 70.0 5 records
opengauss 70.0 5 records
bombadilsystems 70.0 4 records
bizerba 70.0 3 records
tianocore 70.0 3 records
upkeeper 70.0 2 records
jaspersoft 70.0 1 record
opera 70.0 1 record
pentraze 70.0 1 record
sdc 70.0 1 record
softiron 70.0 1 record
eaton 69.8 6 records
oppo 69.5 2 records
bcny 69.25 4 records
fsi 69.2 5 records
bosch 69.13 9 records
sba-research 69.0 8 records
anthropic 68.96 5 records
dahua 68.75 4 records
trellix 68.0 6 records
everpure 68.0 3 records
ncsc-nl 68.0 1 record
windriver 67.9 5 records
vivo 67.6 5 records
secomea 67.5 2 records
netapp 67.28 8 records
gandc 67.0 2 records
hypr 67.0 2 records
asr 67.0 1 record
cloudflare 66.64 9 records
sailpoint 66.0 2 records
securifera 65.0 7 records
seagate 65.0 3 records
airoha 65.0 1 record
fb 65.0 1 record
yokogawagroup 65.0 1 record
pretix 64.8 5 records
txone 64.8 1 record
tibco 64.67 3 records
9front 64.3 2 records
genetec 64.17 6 records
nec 64.14 7 records
insyde 64.12 8 records
sk-cert 63.5 2 records
panasonic_holdings_corporation 62.0 1 record
gallagher 60.0 4 records
spotfire 60.0 1 record
systemd 59.67 3 records
infoblox 59.5 2 records
ciena 57.45 4 records
bugcrowd 57.25 6 records
omnissa 57.0 2 records
oai 53.57 7 records
tecnomobile 53.5 2 records
naver 51.8 2 records
hikvision 49.44 9 records
debian 39.33 3 records

The ranked CNAs graded A over the window: a mean score of 90 or more across their publications.

A
98.62 · 47 records
A
97.2 · 15 records
A
96.86 · 354 records
A
95.07 · 78 records
A
95.0 · 27 records
A
94.28 · 163 records
A
93.8 · 14 records
A
92.5 · 34 records
A
92.06 · 42 records
A
91.56 · 25 records
A
91.23 · 93 records
A
90.6 · 257 records
The rules Each record earns a credit in 0..1 per rule; the record's score is the weighted sum, the assigner's is the mean.

Describe: can a reader tell what the vulnerability is? (25 points)

  • Description (10): An English description that is not a placeholder: full credit from 200 characters, 0.7 from 80, 0.4 from 40, none below.
  • Title (5): A title.
  • Cwe (10): A weakness as a CWE identifier in problemTypes; a free-text problem type without one earns a quarter.

Scope: can a reader tell whether they are affected? (25 points)

  • Affected (10): An affected entry naming both a vendor and a product; one side missing or 'n/a' earns half.
  • Versions (8): An affected entry stating versions, as a version or a bound; a defaultStatus alone earns half.
  • Cpe (7): A CPE on an affected entry, or a cpeApplicability block.

Assess: can a reader tell how bad it is? (25 points)

  • Severity (15): A severity statement in the CNA container: a CVSS v3 or v4 vector, an SSVC decision, or a vendor rating as an 'other' metric. A CVSS v2 vector alone earns half.
  • Modern severity (5): A CVSS v4 vector or an SSVC decision.
  • Impacts (5): An impacts entry (a CAPEC identifier or an impact description).

Act: can a reader tell what to do about it? (25 points)

  • References (7): At least one reference.
  • Reference tags (5): At least one reference carrying tags.
  • Remediation (8): A reference tagged 'patch'; one tagged 'vendor-advisory', 'mitigation' or 'release-notes' earns 0.6.
  • Solutions (5): A solution or a workaround.

Grades: A from 90, B from 75, C from 60, D from 45, E from 0. Timeliness is displayed on each assigner's page and never scored: a long reservation-to-publication delay is a disclosure embargo as often as a backlog. The full text, with the methodology history, is in the documentation.